First I called on the phone and was told to send an email to QA@UpperDeck.com with the redemption code and a list of five teams and/or players whom I collect. I ended up sending Upper Deck a list of nine football players who I collect. The players ranged from future hall of famers, to retired veterans, starters in the NFL, and a few 2nd string players. I wasn't expecting to get any of cards of the players I wanted since none of them were in the 2015 Upper Deck Inscriptions set.
About 2 weeks later I got my redemption replacements in the mail.
In all, I don't think I can complain. I got a red #/75 Jay Ajayi autograph and a red #/75 Ameer Abdullah autograph. Both are backup runningbacks but they played in their first years, so there is some hope that they might actually become starters and decent players some day.
Overall, my Upper Deck redemption replacement request went very smoothly and quickly. I'm happy with the results even though I didn't get any of the players I requested in my email.
